Holding It Together (Kinda)

#6 Companion Who Gets To Decide When Minds Are Unsteady

• Michael Mackniak, Esq

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 3:25

Send us Fan Mail

Client choice can feel like a clean principle right up until the moment symptoms surge, risk rises, and everyone around the person feels responsible for the outcome. I walk through why that moment becomes an ethical tightrope for legal advocates, clinicians, providers, peers, and family members and how quickly “help” can turn into control when we confuse disagreement with incapacity. If you care about mental health advocacy, disability rights, informed consent, and ethical crisis response, this conversation is built for you. 

We dig into the practical work of preserving someone’s autonomy when psychosis or impairment is part of the picture. That starts with protecting the person’s voice: their values, their words, their fears, and their goals, captured clearly instead of overwritten by other people’s opinions. We also talk about the power of documentation and why observable facts and timing beat vague labels like “noncompliant” or “difficult.” When you focus on what happened and when it happened, you create clarity across systems and reduce the chances of a rushed, assumption-driven decision. 

I also explain why disagreement across family members, lawyers, clinicians, providers, and even courts does not automatically mean bad faith. Often it means people are doing their jobs, with different duties pulling in different directions. As a lawyer, that conflict is especially sharp because my role is to do what my client wants, not what everyone else thinks they need. 

Grab the Cloak of Client Choice listener action guide at michaelmachniac.org, then subscribe, share this with someone who navigates tough calls, and leave a review so more people can find the show.

DOWNLOAD THE FREE LISTENER ACTION GUIDE

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HrHl6opiJAKbvBoBvD4clhV92Q-6g1hi/view?usp=drive_link

LISTEN TO HOLDING IT TOGETHER (KINDA)

Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/2nobQzuuYVGKY9NYYWgcvO

YouTube:
Search for HITKINDA

ADDITIONAL FAMILY AND CAREGIVER RESOURCES

Care Coalition Journal:
https://guardian-academy.thinkific.com/courses/CareKeeperJournal

Mental Health Resource Network:
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1296747162391859

Care Coalition:
https://carecoalition.org/

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT

 We are moving to a platform called Discord. Think of it as our own private, invite-only living room.   

JOIN HERE: https://discord.gg/2TCSdfNb

 

I want to be there for you more deeply, but as many of you know, our private Facebook group hasn't been working. It became cluttered, it lacked real privacy, and it turned into a place for people to advertise instead of support one another.

 So, I have shut it down, and I’ve built us a brand-new, private home.

There are no algorithms, no social media noise, and absolutely zero spam or advertising.

I’ve set it up with a Free General Area where you can log in, pull up a chair, and just vent or chat with other caregivers who truly understand your day.

There’s no video required—you don't have to worry about getting dressed up or what your house looks like. You can just listen in and talk to me like a private phone call.

Now, if you aren't tech-savvy, please do not worry. I promise it is simple.

I can’t wait to see you there, talk to you directly, and finally give you the supportive community you deserve. Now, let’s get into today's show."

 How to Join Our Private Care Community (Step-by-Step):

  1. Click this link: https://discord.gg/2TCSdfNb
  2. If you are on a phone, it will prompt you to download the free, secur...

People on this episode